today:
186
yesterday:
242
Total:
1,004,344

Can China Be Sued Over the Coronavirus?

2020.04.12 18:59 Views : 48

I wish I could join the groundswell of opinion demanding that China be held liable for allowing the coronavirus that causes Covid-19 to get out of control. The drumbeat includes, for example, a class action lawsuit filed in Florida last week and the argument that we should treat the outbreak as we would an act of terrorism, because under U.S. law, a country that sponsors terror can’t claim sovereign immunity.

 
 

But I cannot. If you want to argue that the government of China has behaved irresponsibly, that the country’s officials deserve the condemnation of the world for letting the novel coronavirus escape when early action could have kept it under reasonable control, you’ll get no argument from me. The Chinese authorities have chosen denial, censorship and bluster rather than the transparency that might have saved lives. The regime’s transmission of patently false information has made matters worse.

 
 

Legal liability, however, is another matter. The government of China is protected by the doctrine of sovereign immunity, and the regime’s undoubted misconduct does not constitute sufficient grounds for a waiver.

 
 

Sovereign immunity is not a favor courts do for foreign regimes. It’s an act of reciprocity, a peace treaty resting on a shared understanding that we will not allow our people to sue you if you will not allow your people to sue us. So broad is the traditional doctrine that a British court held in 1894  that even if a foreign ruler moves into one’s country, takes on an assumed name and conceals his true position, and enters into a contract, a lawsuit against him for breach is still barred.

No. Subject Date Views
Notice Jon Voight: Pray Donald Trump makes a ‘comeback stronger than ever’ 2022.08.12 540
Notice America's Anthem 2020.12.27 638
306 COVID 19, 한국에서 필수업종과 비필수 업종 2020.04.13 61
305 COVID 19, 한국에서 필수업종과 비필수 업종 2020.04.13 64
» Can China Be Sued Over the Coronavirus? 2020.04.12 48
303 Can China Be Sued Over the Coronavirus? 2020.04.12 44
302 China stifles coronavirus research in apparent bid to control narrative 2020.04.12 47
301 China stifles coronavirus research in apparent bid to control narrative 2020.04.12 41
300 Covid-19 was created by humans in a laboratory in Wuhan, China. 2020.04.12 41
299 Covid-19 was created by humans in a laboratory in Wuhan, China. 2020.04.12 42
298 No,I'm not Chinese file 2020.04.11 76
297 No,I'm not Chinese file 2020.04.11 80
296 Lawsuit against China file 2020.04.11 80
295 Lawsuit against China file 2020.04.11 76
294 casinos, cities seek assistance as coronavirus shutdown 2020.04.10 55
293 casinos, cities seek assistance as coronavirus shutdown 2020.04.10 57
292 Orange County employee tests positive for coronavirus, makes other workers nervous file 2020.04.10 44
291 Orange County employee tests positive for coronavirus, makes other workers nervous file 2020.04.10 37
290 SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA CORONAVIRUS CASES - 04/03/2020 file 2020.04.04 35
289 SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA CORONAVIRUS CASES - 04/03/2020 file 2020.04.04 56
288 Senior residents protest hotel planned for homeless coronavirus patients, operator says it will be isolated and locked down 2020.04.04 71
287 Senior residents protest hotel planned for homeless coronavirus patients, operator says it will be isolated and locked down 2020.04.04 67
286 SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA CORONAVIRUS CASES - 04/01/2020 file 2020.04.01 44
285 SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA CORONAVIRUS CASES - 04/01/2020 file 2020.04.01 51
284 China is responsible for this coronavirus ( COVID-19 ) 2020.03.31 46
283 China is responsible for this coronavirus ( COVID-19 ) 2020.03.31 43
282 Orange County coronavirus cases 2020.03.31 47
281 Orange County coronavirus cases 2020.03.31 49
280 SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA CORONAVIRUS CASES file 2020.03.31 50
279 SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA CORONAVIRUS CASES file 2020.03.31 67
278 Irvine had the highest number of confirmed cases COVID-19 in OC 2020.03.31 44
277 Irvine had the highest number of confirmed cases COVID-19 in OC 2020.03.31 36